How to Determine Salmon Freshness

August 21, 2019

How to Determine Salmon Freshness


Salmon is, by far, North America’s most popular seafood. This great-tasting, fatty fish is chockful of nutrients and can reduce risk factors for several diseases. We trust that you’re familiar with the sight of the pretty pink fish that occasionally sits atop your dinner plate; but here’s the real question: how can you tell if the salmon you’ve bought is fresh?

Recipe By Seafood Crate

Well, you don’t have to be a seafood expert – it all begins with 3 of your primary senses – sight, smell, and touch.


Do not even think about getting that dreary-looking slab of salmon! The first indicator of fresh salmon is its colour: it should always be a lovely, bright pinkish-orange hue. While colours can vary slightly according to salmon species, the key is the brightness of the meat. If your salmon looks dull, pale or discolored, it is not fresh at all and could be spoiled.

But colour can be misleading as some grocery store salmon is treated with tasteless smoke which chemically makes it look fresh even if it’s been sitting on the shelf for days.

Now look a little closer. The white lines on fresh salmon are another sign of freshness. If you need to squint before you can make them out, put the salmon back – it’s no longer fresh.

If you’re purchasing a whole salmon, you have one other way to check for freshness – its eyes. It should have bright, clear eyes that feature a dark pupil. The eyes should also be bulging slightly; steer clear of cloudy and sunken eyes.


Take a good whiff of the salmon. What do you smell? Fresh salmon should have nothing more than a subtle “fishy” scent. If the smell of the meat assaults your nose, we’re willing to bet that it will do the same to your stomach. Be sure to throw out any salmon that doesn’t smell right. Scents that are sour or ammonia-like are a definite no-no.


If the salmon has passed the sight and smell tests, you can go ahead and touch it. Give the salmon a quick rub with your fingers. Don’t be shy… it won’t hurt you!

How does it feel? If the fish has a slimy, milky-white residue on the outside, it’s likely NOT fresh. Note that a good quality cut of salmon will be oily to the touch. This is the Omega 3 fatty acids which are a big reason for salmon’s great taste of nutritional content.

Next give the meat a quick prod to check for consistency. Fresh salmon should always be firm and spring back when pressed. If it feels loose and falls apart easily, it has probably gone bad. 


And there you have it! How to determine salmon freshness is not difficult but getting it fresh can be. Don’t assume that your salmon is fresh, just because you bought it from the grocery store. Think about it: who knows how long that fish has been sitting on the store shelf?

Take the guess work out of the equation! You never have to fret over the freshness of your seafood if you order from Seafood Crate. Our fresh seafood delivery service ensures you’re getting honestly fresh salmon direct from the fishermen – no shelf display, no unnecessary processing, and no wasted time.

Let the seafood experts over at Seafood Crate make a difference in your kitchen.  If convenient seafood delivery and “shore to door” freshness sounds amazing, we’re just one click away! Click here to get started.

Have you tried this recipe or enjoyed our products? Let us know by leaving a review! If you have any questions, please contact us.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in Blogs

Seafood Crate's Year In Review
Seafood Crate's Year In Review

February 26, 2020

We have grown so much in the last year! We started last year with an extended beta launch during the spring and summer. Then we officially launched in the fall.

Read More

Top 5 Tips For Choosing Quality Seafood
Top 5 Tips For Choosing Quality Seafood

November 21, 2019

Our top 5 tips for choosing quality seafood make finding fresh, premium seafood a breeze.

Read More

Stop Paying for Ice: Glaze, The Frozen Fish Fraud
Stop Paying for Ice: Glaze, The Frozen Fish Fraud

August 21, 2019

Read More

★ Reviews

What our customers have to say...

429 reviews
Best fish ever

Just went online and ordered my third purchase of fish, my wife and I love the quality, we are hooked.

superb quality

I order weekly, and each and every time the quality is superb and consistent. The communication from the time or ordering to delivery is friendly and professional. Its been a real life saver at a time when in store shopping is so precarious. highly recommend

Excellent quality

Very fresh seafoods: even the frozen ones. Excellent quality.

Great Customer Service

I have purchased from Seafood Crate for over a year now. Occasionally I have used the chat feature to check on my order and the response has been immediate and very helpful. The delivery service is so reliable and the food has always been carefully and safely packaged. This past week it looked like one part of my order had not been delivered. The person on chat worked with the delivery person to determine the status within minutes. The problem was on my end but Seafood Crate was so helpful in getting it resolved! Love the variety and quality of the products!

Great Seafood

Love the seafood! Always fresh, price is great and they deliver! This is one of the best services I have found for seafood.